How to minimize uncertainty in phosphorus monitoring

Phosphorus is a nutrient that can be harmful to water quality if it is not managed properly. Farmers who are interested in tracking and monitoring phosphorus loss from their fields need to be aware of the different sampling strategies that are available and the impact that these strategies can have on the accuracy of the data.

There are three main sampling strategies that can be used to monitor phosphorus loss: flow-proportional sampling, time-proportional sampling, and grab sampling. Flow-proportional sampling involves collecting water samples in proportion to the flow rate of the drainage water. Time-proportional sampling involves collecting water samples at regular intervals, regardless of the flow rate. Grab sampling involves collecting a single water sample at a specific time.

The choice of sampling strategy will depend on the specific objectives of the monitoring project. For example, if the goal is to track the overall trend in phosphorus loss over time, then flow-proportional sampling may be the best option. However, if the goal is to identify specific events that are associated with high phosphorus losses, then time-proportional sampling or grab sampling may be more appropriate.

It is important to note that the sampling strategy can have a significant impact on the uncertainty of the phosphorus load estimate. For example, grab sampling is the least accurate sampling strategy, as it can miss short-term spikes in phosphorus concentration. Flow-proportional sampling is more accurate than grab sampling, but it can be more expensive and time-consuming. Time-proportional sampling is a compromise between accuracy and cost-effectiveness.

By cautioning farmers against relying on phosphorus concentration alone from grab-sampling to evaluate the phosphorus reduction performance of conservation practices. This is because phosphorus concentration can fluctuate rapidly, so a single grab sample may not be representative of the overall phosphorus load.

By choosing the right sampling strategy, farmers can ensure that they are getting accurate data about phosphorus loss from their fields. This information can then be used to make informed decisions about conservation practices that can help to protect water quality.

Photo Credit: gettyimages-sasiistock